The Ugly Duckling in Your Organisation: How Many Swans Are You Wasting?

Hidden talent, comfortable budgets and taxpayers’ money: why “good enough” is the most expensive mistake a manager can make.

Do you know the story of “The Ugly Duckling”? The duckling that was laughed at, bullied and shut out, and only much later discovered that it was actually a swan?

Who among you has never read this fairy tale by Hans Christian Andersen? Or was it read to you as a child, and are you perhaps now reading it to your own children?

But be honest: have you ever really stopped to think about what this story truly means?

The Right Person in the Wrong Place

In grown-up language, the story is painfully familiar: the right person, in the wrong place, in the wrong environment. Someone who never gets the chance to shine, because nobody sees what is inside them. Least of all themselves.

Because as long as you do not know something, you cannot see it.

That applies to many of us. We are shaped by our family, our relatives and the organisation we work for. Our image of what we are capable of is often the image others have handed to us. And with the right guidance, the right coaching and the right place, such a duckling can go surprisingly far.

Team Spirit or Groupthink?

Belief in your own abilities, and in the organisation you work for, is essential for top performance. Team spirit is what makes an organisation march.

But beware. That same team spirit can quietly tip over into groupthink, as psychologist Irving Janis called it. Everyone nods, nobody asks critical questions anymore, and the organisation marches with full conviction in the wrong direction.

We do not say for nothing: “A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.” But what if that weakest link is not weak at all, but simply in the wrong place?

“But Everything Is Going Fine, Isn’t It?”

How well does your organisation really perform? And how much influence do you have on that yourself?

I can hear you thinking: our revenue and profits are fine, aren’t they? We manage with our budgets, don’t we? Our margins are healthy, our clients are satisfied and they pay our price without complaint.

Wonderful. But isn’t your “tailor-made suit” then just a little too loose? An organisation that runs well is not yet an organisation that performs at its best. It is precisely in good times that waste creeps in unnoticed.

What the Management Classics Teach Us

Much has been written on this question. Henry Mintzberg showed that organisations take different forms, each with its own coordination mechanisms. With his Competing Values Framework, Robert E. Quinn showed that organisational culture and effectiveness are inseparably linked.

And a true masterpiece, in my view, is “Good to Great” by Jim Collins: the research into what separates good organisations from truly excellent ones.

Léon de Caluwé, too, shows with his colour-thinking model that people, and therefore change, do not all work in the same way. Fortunately, we are all different.

The conclusion of all these thinkers is as simple as it is confronting: different organisations, departments and people require a different approach.

Do you approach everyone and every department in your organisation in the same way? Or do you truly look at who is standing in front of you?

When It Is Taxpayers’ Money

Now it gets really interesting. Because what if you are not paid by satisfied customers, but out of taxpayers’ money?

Who likes paying “too much” tax? And who wants to pay for work that is not carried out effectively and efficiently, with that very same taxpayers’ money?

In my opinion, organisations funded from this great common pot must also keep a sharp eye on their costs. This is where money, behaviour, culture, efficiency and effectiveness meet.

But does that happen in the right way? Is that money really spent with the care of a good steward? Do the municipal secretaries of this world behave like responsible custodians? Or is there still a great deal to be gained?

A Practical Example

Take an average municipal organisation. Employees with a wide variety of tasks and responsibilities. The question is: who actually deals with politics, and who does not?

Does politics influence every task? You probably think: yes. And at the moment decisions are made, that is true.

But what happens once the decision has been taken, and the product or service only needs to be delivered in the “factory”: the municipal administration?

May everyone then still hide behind “politics” when work is done inefficiently and ineffectively? Or could that administration simply be managed like a normal office, a shop or a straightforward production company?

How Many Swans Are Swimming in Your Pond?

You are what you think, and what you are told. That applies to people, and it applies to organisations.

So take a good look around you: in your department, in your team, in the mirror. How many swans are still behaving like ugly ducklings, simply because nobody ever told them what they really are?

And of course, I am not comparing people to animals here. But the question remains.

This story is not based on true events. Should any case of mistaken identity have arisen, we hereby offer our sincere apologies.

Ton Bakker

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *